After hearing about how we should be like geese, I decided to do some research and see for myself what was involved in being a goose.
The first thing I came across was the old French proverb:
The first thing I came across was the old French proverb:
It is a stupid goose that listens to a fox preach.Are teachers stupid for listening to administrators preach?
Then I read that Canadian geese drop two to four pounds of excrement a day and create major health problems. They are also extremely noisy.
I also found a bunch of goose meanings here. I decided to just copy a few.
A stupid and inane woman is called "un'oca" (a goose) in Italian as well.
Geese are also "stupid" in idiomatic expressions of German: "dumme Gans - stupid goose": the meaning is "silly/stupid woman". This seems to go back to classical fables - or at least German Wiki lists geese as (supposedly) stupid acording to fables tradition, without reference to a particular fable.
Proverbial behaviour tends to be given to familiar creatures, and geese will have been extremely common and familiar from early times. So this makes them a target for having some sort of attribute assigned to them, and they may not need to be outstandingly stupid for this quality to be associated with them. It's possible that it is simply to do with how they look, move (they are somewhat ungainly on the ground) and some of their behaviours that make them seem comic or ridiculous, rather than unintelligent per se. (They may be fairly intelligent as domesticated birds go, but that's not really saying a great deal.) In English, words like "giddy" and "silly" often accompany proverbial mentions of geese, and perhaps stupidity as such is a perhaps unfair extension of this.In Pulleyn's Etymological Compendium (early 19th c.) the writer (unlike Johnson) finds it self-evident that geese are stupid. He says he only includes them to give examples showing they are not always stupid, which seems self-defeating as an entry in an etymology, but there you go.
Also in Swedish, geese are stupid. I haven't found any particular fables, either, depicting geese as stupid, but it seems to be an widespread European It does exist in Hungarian: hülye liba (stupid goose) idea.
(I guess I am not a big fan of metaphors)


