The best way to evaluate a teacher is to ask their students, the ones who spend multiple hours with them weekly. They have been with this person on good days and bad days. They sat through wonderful lessons and lessons that bombed. They know which teachers get a point across, or do whatever is necessary to get that point across a second or third or tenth time and know which teachers are impossible to learn from. Students know these things. Standardized tests don't. APs, even those who have been at their jobs for more than 5 minutes often miss the point too and those not even trained in the subject they are supervising are clueless.
I just opened an envelope with 27 forms like the one posted above. This time they happened to be all good, but they aren't always as complimentary. Still, mix in a few not so nice ones and anyone can see the type of teacher I am. And yes, there were students in this group who were not passing so the evaluations had nothing to do with ease of grading.
